Married Filing Jointly vs Separately: Which is the Better Option?

May 22, 2023 By Becca Park

When it comes to filing taxes, married people have to decide whether to file jointly or separately. It’s a decision that can impact their finances in several ways. For that reason, it’s important to consider all potential ramifications before filing your taxes.

Married Filing Jointly vs Separately Which is the Better Option

At CMP, we advise our married clients on the best way to file their taxes to minimize their tax burden and maximize the advantages of being married. That said, each couple has unique financial circumstances, and what works for one may not work for another. Here is our guide to choosing married filing jointly vs separately.

Tax Implications of Getting Married

Getting married has tax implications that go beyond choosing a filing status. Here are some of the things you’ll need to know:

  • Name changes: If one spouse is taking the other’s surname, you’ll need to inform the Social Security Administration, so they can update their records.
  • W-4 forms: If one or both of you work, you’ll need to update your W-4 forms with your employer to reflect your marital status.
  • Tax brackets: Your tax bracket may change after you get married, particularly if one spouse has a much higher or much lower income than the other.
  • Capital gains: If one or the other of you owned a home prior to your marriage, getting married can impact how much capital gains you can exclude if you sell the home.

We’ll go into greater detail about tax brackets later in this guide.

Is It Better for a Married Couple to File Separately or Jointly?

One of the questions we hear most frequently from newly married couples is whether it’s more advantageous to file separately or jointly. While there are undeniable advantages to filing jointly, there are some circumstances when filing separately may make sense.

Let’s start with when it makes sense to file jointly. The most obvious scenario is if one spouse will be working, and the other will not. In that situation, filing jointly is advantageous because the 2023 standard deduction for joint filers is $27,700 as compared to $13,850 for people who are married and filing separately. If one spouse is not required to file because they have no income, the couple should file a joint return to take advantage of the higher deduction.

If you have large itemized deductions on the other hand, it may make more sense to file separately to maximize your allowable deductions. There are also advantages to filing separately for couples who are separated and/or planning to divorce.

Overview of Married Filing Jointly

Married couples who file jointly complete a single tax return that reflects their income and all shared assets.

Tax Benefits of Filing Jointly

Here are the most significant benefits of filing jointly as a married couple:

  • Larger standard deduction: As we noted above, there’s a larger standard deduction for married couples that’s advantageous if only one spouse is working.
  • Access to tax credits: Married couples who file jointly may be able to qualify for generous tax credits, including the Earned Income Credit, the American Opportunity Tax Credit, the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit, the Lifetime Learning Credit, and the Saver’s Tax Credit.
  • Higher refund/lower tax burden: By taking advantage of the larger standard deduction and available tax credits, married couples may end up getting a larger refund (or owe less) if they file jointly than they would if they filed separately.

Higher retirement account deductions: Married couples who file jointly can take advantage of higher deductions for their contributions to employer-sponsored retirement plans.

Disadvantages of Filing Jointly

Here are a few potential disadvantages to filing your taxes jointly:

Medical deductions: There’s a limit on medical deductions that says you may deduct these expenses only if they exceed 7.5% of your adjusted gross income. In some cases, filing separately will allow you to deduct more of your medical expenses because your individual income is likely to be lower, making it possible to meet the threshold required by the IRS.

Overview of Married Filing Separately

While there are significant advantages to filing jointly, there are some potential benefits to filing your taxes separately.

Tax Benefits of Filing Separately

Here are some potential advantages to filing separately:

  • No liability for your spouse’s tax debt: If a spouse has reason to mistrust their partner or believes they may not have disclosed their tax liability, filing separately shields each spouse from the other’s tax liability.
  • Medical deductions: As noted above, filing separately may allow for a higher medical expense deduction than filing jointly.

Lower tax bracket: In some cases, filing separately may allow for a lower total tax burden, specifically when one spouse has significantly less income than the other.

Disadvantages of Filing Separately

Finally, here are the disadvantages of filing separately:

  • Lower standard deduction: Couples who file separately must each take a lower standard tax deduction than they would if filing jointly, and in some cases, particularly if one spouse has little or no income, the lower standard deduction can be a disadvantage.
  • Fewer tax credits: As we noted above, couples who file separately lose out on potential tax deductions that may increase their refund or decrease the amount they owe.
  • Two tax returns. The most obvious disadvantage of filing separately is that you must complete two tax returns, which may take more time and cost more than filing a single, joint return.
  • Tax credit exclusions: Couples who file separately won’t be able to take the tax credits that are available only to couples who file jointly.

 Lower IRA contribution deductions: If you file separately, you’ll each be limited in the amount you can deduct based on your retirement account contributions and may save less for retirement as a result.

How Do You Decide Whether to File Taxes Jointly or Separately?

Are you and your spouse better off filing your taxes jointly or separately? In this section, we’ll walk through several ways to address the question and make the best decision for yourself and your finances.

Compare Tax Percentages

One of the easiest ways to gauge the impact of married filing jointly or separately is to look at the tax table for each spouse’s income separately and then combined. Here’s an example:

Spouse 1: Taxable income of $50,000; must pay $5,147 + 22% of the amount over $44,725 for a total tax amount of $6,307.50.

Spouse 2: Taxable income of $200,000; must pay $37,104 plus 32% of the amount over $182,101 for a total tax amount of $42,831.68. Combined with the other spouse, the total tax amount would be $49,139.18.

If we add the two spouses’ incomes together, we get to a total taxable income of $250,000. That would mean the couple must pay $32,580 plus 24% of the amount over $190,750 for a total tax amount of $46,800.

In this simple example, we see that by combining their incomes, this couple would end up paying $2,339.18 less in taxes than they would if they filed separate returns.

Compare Deductions

Another way to decide whether it’s best to file jointly or separately is by calculating each partner’s taxes with deductions and then calculating the combined deductions.

One scenario we’ve already mentioned is if one couple has accrued significant medical expenses during the tax year, filing separately may be advantageous because of the limits on medical deductions. Since you can only deduct expenses that exceed more than 7.5% of your adjusted gross income, it may be preferable to file separately in some circumstances.

Using our example above, let’s imagine that the spouse with the $50,000 income had an adjusted gross income of $44,000. If they had medical expenses of $10,000 during the year, they would have $6,700 in medical expenses they could deduct. (That’s $10,000 less 7.5% of AGI or $3,300.)

If we looked at that $10,000 of medical expenses as a percentage of the couple’s joint adjusted gross income of $230,000, it wouldn’t even come close to making the 7.5% threshold of $17,250.

You may want to compare other deductions as well, particularly if one or both partners own property that’s in their name only, and you don’t live in a community property state. There are limitations on mortgage interest deductions. At the same time, you should also be sure that you’ve taken any deductions that apply to couples who file jointly that you couldn’t take advantage of if you filed separately.

One final note regarding deductions is that if you file separately, you must both choose the same option for deductions. By that we mean that if one of you takes the standard deduction, you must both take it; if one of you itemizes deductions, you will both need to do so or the spouse who doesn’t itemize will receive a standard deduction of zero.

Consider Tax Liability and Transparency

Depending upon your circumstances, you may also want to look at your tax status from the standpoint of tax liability and transparency. When one spouse believes that the other may have hidden their tax liability or income, it may be best to file separately.

Separate filings can help shield a spouse from their partner’s wrongdoing when it exists. It can minimize the risk that a spouse will be held liable for their partner’s taxes if there’s an issue. For this reason, couples who are separated or in the process of a divorce may choose to file separately.

Tips for Making the Most of Filing Jointly vs Filing Separately

Here are some tips for making the most of your tax filing status, whichever option you choose:

  • Keep in mind that according to the IRS, you are married for the entire tax year if you were married on the final day of the tax year. Couples who get married toward the end of a year get the same tax benefits as couples who were married for the entire year.
  • If you’re unsure which option will be most advantageous for you, we recommend doing side-by-side calculations to compare. Comparing joint tax returns with separate returns will highlight the advantages and disadvantages of each option.
  •  Keep your retirement savings in mind; The deduction limits for contributions to work-sponsored retirement plans are significantly higher if you file jointly than they are if you file separately.
  • Couples who live in a community property state may want to hire a tax professional to assist with their returns. This distinction is particularly important if you are considering filing separately. As of this writing, Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin are all community property states.

These tips can help you evaluate your options and choose the filing option that makes the most sense for you and your financial situation.

Final Thoughts on Married Filing Jointly vs Separately

The decision of whether to file your tax returns jointly or separately deserves careful consideration and may require assistance from an experienced tax professional to ensure you take advantage of all available tax credits.

Do you need advice about filing taxes with your spouse? CMP is here to assist you! Read about our income tax services and schedule a free consultation today.

Schedule A Consultation Now.

Subscribe to Email Updates